Dinosaurs found in Dubbo...just not in the Zoo!
Ashleigh and Nicole Sykes won't be smiling today as the league kicks off in Dubbo...without them!
There are no dinosaurs in Dubbo Zoo but they are alive and well in the local football association.
The Daily Liberal, the local Dubbo paper, reports today that Matildas stars and local Dubbo twins Ashleigh and Nicole Sykes have been training to play with a local team in the Under 18 League.
Guess what?
It's a boys league and Jim Auld and the Local Association has said NO!
Here's the article: And don't forget to add your comment at the end of the story.
Jim said this:
“Ashleigh and Nicole Sykes are really competent and delightful young ladies with a lot of natural talent and I have a lot of time for both of them,” Mr Auld said.
And this:
“But this is just one of those things - it is a male competition, just like there are female competitions which boys would not be able to play.
And he even said this:
“It is common sense that their risk of injury would be increased if they played men and I would hate for them to get injured and jeopardise their careers.
Arguments from othersas to why the girls can't play have included, "they may get hurt, referee may treat them differently based on gender or other players may back off when contesting a ball."
Stop laughing people still really say that stuff publicly!
Come on Dubbo: Never heard of Millissa Barbieri in Victoria...playing boys football...and she's in goals!!!
You've even got a letter from National Coach Tom Sermanni...Jim, do you understand the game better than Tom and the capabilities of our elite female players?
And it's not like you will have 50 girls desperate to play the game at that level is it?
Jim methinks you are going to be a popular man across Aussie media this week...take the phone off the hook...NOW!
Full article below.
Canberra United W-League stars Ashleigh and Nicole Sykes have been denied the right to play for Dubbo Football Club in this year’s Western Premier League competition.
The twins have been training with the club and were hoping to play with the under-18s side this season as part of preparations for the Under-20 World Cup qualifiers in August.
However, with the first round of matches tomorrow, which sees the Bulls pitted against Canobolas Rangers at Lady Cutler Oval, the league has stated it will not allow the Sykes girls to take the field based on the grounds that it is a men’s competiton.
The twins were yesterday training in Canberra under the guidance of Australian Matildas coach Tom Sermanni who himself reportedly requested they play in the under-18s competition.
The girls and their family were hoping to be able to play in a strong competition locally, considering they will be undertaking Year 12 and the travel demands of being in the Matildas and Canberra United squads were already limiting their time to study.
But this will not be the case.
Instead the girls could be deprived of valuable match time which would help to keep up with the physical demands of playing on the international stage.
Ashleigh and Nicole’s father Derek Sykes said he felt the decision by the WPL was upsetting and was not encouraging for aspiring female soccer players in western New South Wales.
“What hurts most is the girls want to stay in Dubbo to complete their HSC and still play competitive soccer,” Mr Sykes said.
“It’s unfortunate the WPL won’t help a couple of kids from out west.
“They have been enjoying their training with the boys who have been supportive and welcoming.
“It is upsetting when you look at what they have put back into the Dubbo community and have pushed Dubbo at every chance. What hope does it give for younger kids coming through?”
Before their rise to stardom the girls played in the Dubbo under-15 to 17 competition with boys. Sykes said this competition and the Dubbo Women’s All-Age competition would not provide the girls with the pace of game they needed to further develop their game.
He argued that at an international level the women play just as hard as the boys and that most of the W-League players do play in men’s competitions of a similar standard.
WPL co-ordinator Jim Auld said the rules stipulated that the league was strictly a men’s competition.
“Ashleigh and Nicole Sykes are really competent and delightful young ladies with a lot of natural talent and I have a lot of time for both of them,” Mr Auld said.
“But this is just one of those things - it is a male competition, just like there are female competitions which boys would not be able to play.
“It is common sense that their risk of injury would be increased if they played men and I would hate for them to get injured and jeopardise their careers.
“There are other female competitions on a par with the WPL under-18s, such as playing for Bathurst Panthers in the Super League. There is travel involved but there is also travel involved in the WPL.”
10 comments:
Everyone can have a whinge for being politically incorrect but he is absolutley right...people just don't like hearing it publicly. He is being honest and kudos to him, at least he has the guts to say it.
He's right is he? Forget the whinge, mine, or yours.
Let's go with the evidence:
Girls have been training with Under 18's team so far..so Coach, girls, parents and boys can easily make an assessment if it will work for all parties. Seems they all have agreed it can.
Tom Sermanni Coach of Matildas would not put them in if he thought it was unsafe and not worthwhile.
And there is a fair chance the girls are fitter if no faster than most in the league. No disrespect but it's hardly the greatest league in Australia is it in terms of fitness and standard...WPL Under 18's.
He may have the guts to say it...but the evidence points to him being wrong.
And the evidence is not about political correctness whatever that means...
let the debate begin:)
WHO CARES??
There were a few ACT players at the camp for the Matildas last weekend. Lets hear about ACT players on an ACT football blog.
What a joke?! Classic case of pushy parents thinking their kids are great. How on earth did they think they would play U18 mens. They are too small and light. They both easily got pushed off the ball like flies in the W Leage and U18 men would easily take them out. Neither of them have got any football skills to counteract this either.
Get real girls, play at the level of your ability not your ego
Everyone has views on individual players.
But the real issue is not about individual players, but about opportunities for women to play football at all levels, whether it is in rural NSW, Canberra or anywhere in Australia.
All women who aspire to elite football, have to juggle careers and football, or school and football.
They all need to be supported and promoted.
Well if it is not about individual players, why make the article about individuals. All elite women players face the same issues. Make it a general article focussing on all players, not picking out individuals.
Every story should be treated on it's own merits, this just happens to be two girls that have been unfairly treated. When you get pushed aside by people who's job it is to promote and nurture talent there's something wrong with that.Iv'e seen them play and thay could handle it in fact they could run rings around a lot of players in this competition. They have already played against alot of these players in past years.
Hi All, As the father of the girls you really don't know the family or the situation. How do you think the girls are going to IMPROVE - playing with 15 year olds? or travelling 6 hours each way to play a game of football each weekend. We'd love to move to a major city but can't. Girls will move themselves when school finishes is a few months and most likely to the ACT - so I guess you will be stuck with sub quality players then. This is a choice they made to play and we don't push them or over rate their skills in anyway, they have their faults and are trying to fix them. This did find its way to Eamonn to open up discussion about females playing elite football not about personalities. I have no problems in "pushing" that point of veiw as much as possible and for that matter pushing football in the ACT. We travelled to every home game and games in Sydney and even the road trip to Bris for the final. Yes to support our girls, Canberra United and womens football in Australia. Wake up!
So many negative people.
Oh by the way my name is Derek.
Put your names to your comments.
Hi All, As the father of the girls you really don't know the family or the situation. How do you think the girls are going to IMPROVE - playing with 15 year olds? or travelling 6 hours each way to play a game of football each weekend. We'd love to move to a major city but can't. Girls will move themselves when school finishes is a few months and most likely to the ACT - so I guess you will be stuck with sub quality players then. This is a choice they made to play and we don't push them or over rate their skills in anyway, they have their faults and are trying to fix them. This did find its way to Eamonn to open up discussion about females playing elite football not about personalities. I have no problems in "pushing" that point of veiw as much as possible and for that matter pushing football in the ACT. We travelled to every home game and games in Sydney and even the road trip to Bris for the final. Yes to support our girls, Canberra United and womens football in Australia. Wake up!
So many negative people.
Oh by the way my name is Derek.
Put your names to your comments.
To be brutally honest, neither of these two would be up to playing in a boys U/18 league, even in Dubbo.
Post a Comment